
UofL Health’s Dr. Jay Grider on easing capacity crunches and winning over skeptical clinicians
The president of UofL Health’s acute hospitals talked with us about moving patients to open beds, removing the ‘stones in the shoe’ and why improvement has to start with frontline teams.
Chicago - On some days, the busiest emergency department in the UofL Health system is packed with patients waiting for beds, while hospitals a short drive away have dozens of empty ones.
Dr. Jay Grider is changing how patients move through the system to fix that. “You're not admitted to Hospital X. You're admitted to University of Louisville Health, and we will get you to the proper location,” he says.
Grider became president of acute hospitals for UofL Health, a five-hospital system in Kentucky, about six months ago. He says he started by stabilizing a workforce that had been squeezed by cost cuts, and is now working to cut excess hospital days and wait times, coordinating ambulance runs to move patients from the crowded university hospital to hospitals with open beds.
He says lasting improvement has to come from the people doing the work. “Every operational improvement initiative that starts in a C-suite should just be stopped immediately,” Grider says. “It has to start at the front line with the people that are doing the work.”
Grider spoke with Chief Healthcare Executive® while he was in Chicago for the Becker's CEO + CFO Roundtable earlier this month. He talked about balancing efficiency with quality, the early warning signs that staff are wearing down, and how he wins over skeptical clinicians by first removing the “stones in their shoe.”
This is one of a series of interviews with leaders at the Becker’s conference. Look for more in the coming days.
Here is a transcript of our conversation with Dr. Jay Grider.
Q: Your Becker's panel focuses on balancing efficiency and quality during transformation. Where do health systems most often get that balance wrong?
Grider: “The balance between efficiency and quality really comes down to ensuring that your efforts to drive throughput don't in some way harm patient outcomes. Your length of stay work, any of your readmissions work, those sorts of things all have the downstream potential, obviously, to be deleterious to patient care if done in the wrong spirit. That's why I believe it's really important that health systems have physicians and nurse leaders really high within the organization, to make sure those efforts don't have those impacts.
“The operational efficiency pieces can boil down to just straight numbers, but you have to make sure that the clinician aspects are always at the forefront. And sometimes you choose to be inefficient because it's what's optimally best for an individual patient outcome.
“But for the most part, that balance comes from having experienced clinicians who understand the finances, who understand the operational throughput and who understand the clinical realities on their front lines to drive those things. Everybody's front line can be a little bit different, so it's understanding the nuances of your particular culture and your particular patient population. It is a balance, but they are not mutually exclusive.”
Q: As president of UofL Health’s acute hospitals, what changes have you made that improved efficiency without hurting the quality of care?
Grider: “I am relatively new in my role; I've been there about six months. So the first piece is to learn the ins and outs of the organization. But the biggest issue that we had was workforce stabilization. Financial distress is hitting a lot of the hospitals in the Midwest and certainly in Kentucky. So it's balancing the financial distress with workforce optimization, making sure that we are paying our people in an appropriate fashion, and then focusing on what we can do to actually [improve] throughput.
“For instance, we are a five-hospital system, and we're trying to optimize certain locations with certain service lines. So how do I make sure that patients get from Hospital A to Hospital B to get the care that they need, and get the transfer taken care of? Those are the efficiencies that I'm really working on at this point.
“We also had a series of decisions that had led to a lot of excess days within our system, and we're working with the physician practice and the nursing practice to say, how do we get these excess days out? In some ways, it was one of the lower performers in the Vizient cohort for academic medical centers. So it's focusing on excess days, understanding where those delays are and overcoming the tolerance. We'd gotten to where we'd perhaps tolerated inefficiency in the name of, ‘Well, we're complex.’ Well, because we're complex, we actually have to be more on our game, because inefficiencies can harm people in dramatic ways.”
“Because we're complex, we actually have to be more on our game, because inefficiencies can harm people in dramatic ways.”
Q: How do you know whether an efficiency effort is starting to affect patient outcomes or staff? What early warning signs do you watch for?
Grider: “Understanding the wear on both staff and on the patient from your efficiency work is key. Patients will often feel the benefit from the efficiency work a lot faster. They'll say, ‘Man, I've been here multiple times, but the admission process in the ED was smoother this time.’ But the warning signs in your staff are more staff call-ins and your staff engagement starting to go down.
“You have to make sure that you're really equipping your nurse leaders from a leadership standpoint. A lot of times, it's next person up, sort of a battlefield promotion: ‘Well, Jim was a great bedside nurse,’ or ‘Sue was a great shift leader, so we're going to make them the manager.’ But you've got to make sure that we're equipping people to know how to lead and know how to keep the stress down.
“The other thing is, no matter what is happening, I want to describe our results in terms of patient throughput and patient outcomes, because the budget in any health system is the amalgamation of all the new patient visits into the system and all the discharges from that hospital. So I never want to talk about finances to the front line. What I want to talk about is, how do we get patients in in an effective and efficient manner? How do we get them through their episodes of care and out?
“I view every hospitalization, and really every episode of care, as a series of waiting in between little bursts of care. The patient comes in, they get some testing done, then they wait, they wait, they wait. Then they get some imaging done, and they wait, they wait, they wait. How do I decrease those waiting intervals to only what is necessary to see if the treatment is effective, and not just inherently built into the system throughout the continuum of the stay?”
Q: Capacity is a challenge for many hospitals. How are you approaching length of stay, patient flow and discharge delays across your hospitals?
Grider: “Capacity being a challenge for every hospital is absolutely the truth. In our particular system, and every system is different, we have one major university hospital with a very busy ED, which is cramming patients into one facility. Down the street, literally 0.3 miles, we have a second hospital that is sitting with 60 empty beds, and then we have another community hospital about a mile and a half, two miles away, that has another 80 or 90 empty beds.
“So I'm working on saying, you're not admitted to Hospital X. You're admitted to University of Louisville Health, and we will get you to the proper location. It requires a lot of moving parts from EMS and ambulance movement. We've just done some contracting with local ambulance providers to say we may need up to 10 or 12 [ambulance] runs a day to move patients between Hospital X and Hospital Y to get them into the proper place. So the idea that you just showed up at Hospital X doesn't mean that you'll be admitted there. You'll be admitted where the care is safest.
“Patients may say, ‘Well, I want to stay here.’ But if we continue to cram into that location, staying here may end up in a 36-, 48- or 72-hour wait within our ED for a bed on some days. That's not good for your care. Nobody wants to spend 36 hours in a bed with a fluorescent light in an ED. We can get you to a hospital location and into a better care environment if you just let us work to move you just a touch.”
Q: When you ask frontline teams to change how they work, how do you keep them engaged rather than burned out?
Grider: “Whenever you're trying to get frontline teams to change their work, they have to be the ones who drive it. Every operational improvement initiative that starts in a C-suite should just be stopped immediately. It has to start at the front line with the people that are doing the work. I know that's become a cliché as people have spent 30 years learning lean processes, but the trick is to actually do that. The trick is not to come up with the scheme at the board level or at the C-suite conference table, but to really go, ‘OK, you do the work. How do we redesign this to function in your environment?’ That's the way that they actually start to work on their own burnout, if they are truly the ones driving and innovating change.
“I came in wanting to put a clinical operating system or a management system in place to do just that, and what I realized is that asking people to improve the way they are swimming when they are up to their nose in water, and in some ways drowning, isn't well received. So the first thing I could do to work on frontline process improvement was to stabilize the workforce: the techs, the nurses, the individuals on the front line who perhaps had gotten trimmed in some cost-cutting measures and were really feeling the stress of poor workflows and razor-thin margins to manage within.
“I had to get that workforce stabilization first. Once we've proven to them that we can [deliver] on workforce stabilization, we can start to say, ‘OK, now how do we improve the work that you're doing?’ It doesn't mean we stop it. It just means that working on process when they feel like they are constantly being trimmed is not necessarily the way to go. Most health systems are in an environment now where they are so cost-conscious that they may be cutting pretty close to the bone. So you've got to keep a close eye on that.”
Q: As a physician leader, how do you get clinicians to buy into operational change?
Grider: “Boy, that's the tough one, because most clinicians at this point have been there before. At the organization I've been at, they have seen multiple mergers and multiple dissolutions of mergers. I start right up front by saying, ‘I realize that I am the latest in a series of chuckleheads that have come to you in a suit, talking about what we want to do. And I realize that you're three or four mergers in. You're still here. You've been here 20 years. You've seen me come and go four or five times.’
“So I say this to them: Every Sunday night for years, I would look at my wife and say, ‘I'm going to start a diet.’ And a couple of Sunday nights, something different happened, and four or five months later, I would be down several pounds. But most Sunday nights, nothing different happened. Occasionally, two or three times in my life, lightning struck, and something changed. What I try to get them to believe is, perhaps this is that time when lightning is striking and change can start to occur.
“And what I tell them is, ‘I don't want you to do one thing. What I want you to do is give me three or four stones in your shoe, things that are driving you crazy, and let us work on removing those. And if we're successful in improving a couple of those things, would you then engage with me around perhaps some bigger things that you have given up hope could actually change?’ So my goal is to deliver on some things.
“Usually, the things that are driving physicians and APPs crazy are actually fairly small things that you could correct if you just decided to do it. We're so busy talking to them about service line finance or supply chain reduction or length of stay reduction, and they're like, ‘Could somebody just make it easier for me to schedule a case?’ Sure, we can think about how we do that. Let me remove a stone or two from your shoe before I ask you to start joining me in rolling this boulder up a hill. That's my approach.
“Has it worked? There are some folks who say it's a different approach than they've heard. Time will tell if it's successful or not.”
“Let me remove a stone or two from your shoe before I ask you to start joining me in rolling this boulder up a hill.”
Q: Where is technology, including AI, actually helping your hospitals run more efficiently, and where are you being cautious?
Grider: “In our organization, we are digging our way out of a negative financial situation. So quite frankly, with a lot of the technological advances people are bringing, there are some technologies around clinical operating systems, and around the ability to use AI to analyze finances and set up throughput analysis, that we are having trouble financing at this point. Some of those technologies are a little unproven, and they can be expensive.
“So we are actually being very, very cautious. We're rolling out ambient listening for our nursing staff and for our physicians. Most people are at the stage where they're doing those things to help with note writing and to help with discharge summary creation. Those are pretty standard things.
“But the more sophisticated things, where you're looking at OR scheduling and throughput, and trying to predict that if you send this patient out, you will free up more resources than if you send that patient out first, some of those things are nascent in our organization. Proving their worth is tough. It's still the old pen-and-paper, tried-and-true sorts of things that are working at the moment.
“You can spend a lot of money on some technological solutions and not necessarily have a whole lot to show for it. We've been working with some companies that are looking at OR smoothing and OR flow, and unless you have a good operation around it, you still don't pick up those benefits. So it boils down to how you execute. They have information, they have data, they can show you what you look like. But are you willing to do the hard work of changing the way you function?”
Q: Health systems have been cutting close to the bone while facing regulatory and reimbursement pressures. How are you telling that story to people who point to affordability and rising costs?
Grider: “People talk about spiraling healthcare costs, and one of the easy buttons to push is, ‘Well, physicians are a cost center.’ Physicians are being targeted by the government or by health insurers as a cost. But they're in a sustainable growth rate, and their costs are not actually changing all that dramatically. They have been holding pretty steady at between 5% and 8% of healthcare costs for quite some time. So there's very little juice to squeeze out of that. Most physicians have a very comfortable lifestyle, so it's easy to make them the target, but that's not where the savings really are.
“Where you're getting runaway cost is that every effort that has come down the pike to decrease healthcare costs comes with regulatory burden that actually far exceeds the savings it generates. Every idea, like the MIPS program and a lot of the government programs where you're submitting data, and a lot of the Medicare Advantage programs where they want you to submit data. The latest is TEAM [the Transforming Episode Accountability Model], and we looked at it and said the downside risk is not worth the upside, and the regulatory burden just to report it was gigantic.
“We were part of a state-directed payment program in Kentucky where we have actually dramatically moved the needle on Medicaid outcomes, but the amount of reporting that is required is so outrageous. If you could strip that down to pay your nursing staff better, pay your techs better, pay the frontline staff better so that you could retain them, so they're not constantly churning and hopping across the street for 25 cents, healthcare outcomes would improve. A lot of the regulatory administrative burden is where the waste is currently, and every effort to make that better seems to only add another layer of cost.”
(Jennifer Dye conducted the interview in Chicago. Chris Mazzolini and Austin Littrell contributed.)
Related to this article








